
I am a part of a group chat that hundreds of Illinois injury lawyers from across all fields are a part of. It is really helpful as we share information, discuss cases and how to best win them and generally work toward helping clients.
As part of this group chat, there was a conversation about who is the biggest hired gun IME. A lot of names were said, but there were three in particular that were heavily discussed.
If you are not aware, IME stands for independent medical examination. It gives the insurance company/employer the right to send you to a one time exam with a doctor of their choosing. That doctor is not there to give you medical treatment. They are there to offer an opinion as to what your injury is, is it work related and what future treatment and time off work you need if any.
For an overview of IME’s, here is everything we have written about it. Illinois IME Overview
In theory, this doctor should just give an honest opinion. Doctors are supposed to “do no harm” according to their oath. In reality, it is a big business for many of them. Some make more than seven figures every year from these exams.
Who Is The Worst IME Doctor In Illinois?
Most of the doctors who do IME’s are orthopedics. That makes sense because most work injuries involve treatment by orthopedic doctors. There is one in particular who was described in a bunch of colorful ways by various lawyers on this chat, including:
- “He is a Whore with a capital W. Worst one around.”
- “He does around 200 of these exams every year. I have seen around 75 reports from him and they all read the same. Only one time did he agree with the treating doctor.”
- “I’m convinced he uses AI to generate these reports. They are so similar and have common mistakes associated with AI like messing up the actual surgery date.”
There were a bunch of other interesting comments to say the least.
The most relevant is that he pretty much never agrees with the treating doctor. If you ever have an injury and go for a second opinion, you will find that doctors tend to agree with each other’s findings over 90% of the time. That is because the treating doctor usually gets it right. And those doctors are only motivated to help you. IME doctors are motivated by their pocketbook. If they hurt hundreds of people along the way, they have their yacht and multiple homes to make them feel better.
So Am I Screwed If I Get Sent To One Of These Doctors?
The good news is that not only do lawyers know who the hired gun IME doctors are, but so do the Arbitrators who make rulings on Illinois workers’ compensation cases. They are not dummies and even ones that tend to lean toward favoring the insurance company do not usually give any credibility to these bad faith physicians.
The bad news is that an IME like this could be used to deny your benefits. It can take 3-6 months before you can get a trial hearing because your attorney has to take a deposition of your treating doctor and the IME. So it is certainly possible that your claim will be wrongly denied for a bit before you get a ruling in your favor.
And that is why insurance companies continue to use these doctors. They know that they have no credibility, but it gives them cover to act badly and put pressure on you. Their hope is that you will be financially desperate and need to settle your case too soon or forgo medical treatment that you need.
It is why having an attorney file the case BEFORE the IME is so important. We can be prepared to strike back quickly so any delay has minimal effect on your life. We also often have pre-trials before the Arbitrator if we know they are aware of how bad the IME doctor is so they can make clear to the defense attorney and insurance company that they are fighting a losing battle.
A good lawyer can also prepare you for the IME, including properly documenting what happened which will aid in taking that doctor’s deposition.
____________________________________________________________________________________________
If you have any questions or concerns about an IME or want a free case review, please call us any time at 312-346-5578. We have a state wide network of great lawyers and would love to help you.








